by Lyn Edwin Cathey

Back to back stays at two very upscale hotels in the Miami / Ft Lauderdale area of South Florida provided a real eye opening opportunity to compare value…what you get for what you pay.

First there was a three night stay at the Ritz Carlton South Beach, followed a few days later by two nights at the Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort.

These two stays left me pondering – to what extent do our expectations shape our experience? After all, the Ritz is the Ritz! The aura of exclusivity gives one license to do some serious name dropping…to say…nonchalantly…to fellow worker bees at the office…”Prince William and Kate were so disappointed that we had to depart early, but a lovely suite awaited us at the Ritz.”

The Ritz Carlton - a symbol of distinction and luxury

The Ritz Carlton - a symbol of distinction and luxury

The Ritz –

But take away the brand name and associated expectations and what are you left with? What if there were “blind tastings” for hotel rooms? What if we had had the same room and service experiences without knowing which brand hotel we were in? Then – post stays – still not knowing the brands,  told that one room cost $599 per night, the other $299 – which price tag would we assign to which room?

Ritz Carlton & Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort promoted side by side

Ritz Carlton & Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort promoted side by side

(One well known, high profile booking site recently promoted these two hotels side by side…and the price difference was even greater, albeit for dates two months apart.)

The room at the Ritz was a ‘Deluxe Partial Oceanview’ with private balcony overlooking the pool area. (I was so excited when I read that, having never before seen a “partial ocean”.)

A very informative and personable bellman escorted us to a well-appointed room of about 375 sq. ft. – spotlessly clean, elegantly decorated – with a bathroom that seemed carved whole from a solid block of marble.

Surprisingly, there were a couple of glitches that one would not expect in a hotel of Ritz caliber.

Every other time the toilet was flushed it would run continuously – until the back was opened up and the little valve thing-a-ma-jiggy was tapped.

The shower was huge – beautiful to behold, made of floor to ceiling etched glass – but it leaked. Anyone going to the toilet area within an hour or two of a shower needed hip waders to stay dry.

And, lastly, one of two telephones – the cordless one on the desk – did not work. Checking plugs, connections and much pushing of random buttons did not remedy the situation.

The front desk was told of these little annoyances on the first day of a three day stay and we were informed that a maintenance person would be “sent right up”. When we checked out on Sunday none of the three issues had been addressed.

Bottom line on the Ritz –

You would think that a hotel brand obsessed with perfection – and priced accordingly – would never allow such aforementioned room malfunctions to persist.  Otherwise, the Ritz Carlton South Beach is a lovely little boutique hotel located right smack dab middle of all the SOBE action (South Beach). Great restaurants, night clubs and upscale shops populate the blocks surrounding the hotel. The staff is very well trained, knowledgeable and friendly. The hotel has direct beach access. It is the place to be for SOBE hipsters, or wannabe jet setting hipsters (All pretense aside, not my tribe…my ‘jet done set’ a long time ago).

The Hilton Ft. Lauderdale Beach Resort –

Three days after leaving the Ritz we checked in to the Hilton for a two night pre-cruise stay. Where the South Beach Ritz fronted the beach, the Hilton was across Ft. Lauderdale Beach Blvd from the beach.  The Hilton lobby was beautiful, of similar size and decor to the Ritz – but with room location layout much easier to comprehend. (Somehow we managed to get lost trying to return to our room at the Ritz.  This was in spite of  being escorted by a very chatty bellman who insisted on demonstrating how each and every little button and light switch worked. In hindsight, we should have left a trail of breadcrumbs when leaving the room…and have asked the bellman to do a test flush of the toilet .)

The Hilton room was a Junior Suite – comprising a living room with couch, desk , large flat screen TV, kitchenette and balcony with sliding glass door – plus a separate bedroom with king bed, a second TV and another balcony with glass door (see “balcony view” image). The two room suite was spacious spotlessly clean, very contemporary in decor and – I’m guessing here – around 600 sq. ft. combined.

Bottom line on the Hilton – 

What was missing from the Hilton experience relative to the Ritz? Well, we didn’t have the chatty, oh-so-informative escort to our room – although I’m sure that would have been an option had we requested it. Bragging rights were reduced by one rating star. We had to cross the boulevard to get to the beach. That “partial ocean” was nowhere to be seen – instead we had a beautiful view of the Atlantic. Food and service were the equal of the Ritz and the staff equally congenial, if not a bit more so.

So,  if this had been a “blind tasting” with brand names hidden, how would we assign the respective $599 and $299 price tags?

Both experiences were highly enjoyable, very upscale – so it would be a tough call. But – forced to choose – I would assign the higher price tag to the Hilton Ft. Lauderdale Beach Resort.

An interesting question to close with – how much does ‘brand name’ alone influence experience? How much extra are you willing to pay for that distinction?

Admittedly, I do like bragging about staying at the Ritz – but when disassociated from all “branding” – the Hilton Ft. Lauderdale Beach Resort was the preferable experience.

Click here to book a stay at the Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort.


Entrance to Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort

Entrance to Hilton Hotel Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort

Balcony view from our Junior Suite at the Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort

Balcony view from our Junior Suite at the Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort

Lobby of the Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort

Lobby of the Hilton Ft Lauderdale Beach Resort

View from our balcony of the Ritz Carlton pool area

View from our balcony of the Ritz Carlton pool area


2 Responses to A Tale of Two Hotels

  1. I was thinking the same thing after Pebble Beach! I just don’t see it. It is kind of homely!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please take a second to verify that you are a REAL PERSON! (required) Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.